7. Not A Second Time

“It’s commonly identified as the first Beatles recording to not include all four of them playing, even though that’s not actually true - they are all included. ”

When The Beatles first broke through, they attracted the attention of the non-teenage population primarily because of the madness of Beatlemania, and because of their outrageous haircuts. Some adults recognised that the music was appealing, but many saw their success as a triumph of marketing and gimmickry over substance. Typical of the attitude was an article in the Sunday Telegraph on September 1st, 1963 called “Pop Goes the Whimper”. In it, the journalist described Liverpool as ‘the breeding ground of guitar-bashing, hoarse-voiced, money-spinning talent’ (Rees 2022).

Even for teenagers, The Beatles’ music wasn’t the only thing driving their appeal. Also important were their good looks, their charisma and their humour. But of course, their music was hugely important too. There are numerous quotes from people who were young Beatles fans in 1963 or 1964 describing how they were knocked sideways by their first hearing of a Beatles song. It was a life-changing experience for many.

In some ways, the fact that their music could have such a strong impact is remarkable. It’s not like they invented new notes or new chords or new rhythms. The Beatles’ music was an evolution from several well-established forms of popular music: rock and roll, rhythm and blues, country and western, and styles their parents listened to. Knowing that, there seems to be no reason to expect their music to have the huge impact it had, and continues to have.

In fact, they were doing what innovators always do; they were combining existing ingredients and coming up with something new. The elements were familiar, but the combination of melody, harmony, chords, rhythm, song structure and energy that they concocted was like an iPhone compared with previous phones and computers. It wasn’t fundamentally new, but it was new enough to be wonderfully exciting. You could hear some similar harmonies in songs by the Everly Brothers or The Shirelles or melodies like that from Buddy Holly or energy like that from Little Richard, but none of those artists ever created anything as incredible as “Please Please Me”, or “She Loves You” or “If I Fell”.

Remarkably, The Beatles got even better at it with experience.  Most of their best-loved and most critically acclaimed songs are from 1965 or later, but we shouldn’t forget that they were already producing amazing music before 1965.

One way to try to understand what makes a piece of music amazing is to analyse it using musical theory. These days there is nothing at all remarkable about musicians applying musical theory to analyse Beatles songs. The Beatles themselves had no formal musical training – they were self-trained drawing on their extensive and wide-ranging experience - but what they came up with was so engaging, surprising and intriguing that it begged for a musical analysis.

But initially this was lost on most serious musicians and musicologists, meaning classically trained ones. Their judgements and attitudes were clouded by news reports of screaming teenage girls and police operations to control crowds, and when exposed to early Beatles records they mainly heard abrasive instrumental sounds played too loudly, punctuated by John and Paul screaming.

{extract from “Twist and Shout”}

December 27, 1963 was the date when this started to change, at least in the UK. That’s the date when The Times published an article titled “What Songs The Beatles Sang” by William Mann, their senior music critic. Here are some of his comments.

“But harmonic interest is typical of their quicker songs too, and one gets the impression that they think simultaneously of harmony and melody, so firmly are the major tonic sevenths and ninths built into their tunes, and the flat submediant key switches, so natural is the Aeolian cadence at the end of “Not A Second Time” (the chord progression which ends Mahler’s Song of the Earth).

{extract from “Not A Second Time”}

The Beatles were bemused by the article. They didn’t need to understand music theory to create this music. I imagine that to them the idea of describing music in this way seemed silly because it was completely unnecessary. Can’t you just listen to it and enjoy it? To them it would have felt pompous and elitist. It may also have felt implicitly incompatible with their philosophy of never repeating themselves – always seeking to create something new. Why bother describing a musical device if your main objective is never to use it again?

Eight years later, John acknowledged that the article, “made us credible with intellectuals … it did us a lot of good in that way because people in all the middle classes and intellectuals were going ‘oooh’” (Wenner 1971).

It didn’t stop John from being quite rude about William Mann. Later John said. “He used a whole lot of musical terminology and he’s a twit. I still don’t know what it means at the end, but he made us acceptable to the intellectuals. It worked, and we were flattered. I wrote ‘Not A Second Time’ and really it was just chords like any other chords. To me, I was writing a Smokey Robinson or something at the time.” (The Beatles 2000, p.96).

So, despite some reservations, the article made an impression on them. They realised that it contributed to a growing acceptance of their music among adults. Mann’s use of incomprehensible jargon supported his “claim that the Beatles’ music is more sophisticated than most readers of The Times might have assumed” (Capitain 2018).

The fact that more and more adults came to appreciate The Beatles’ music was also a remarkable development. Up to this point, rock and roll and pop music were looked on with disdain by many adults. That included The Beatles’ early records. George Martin later observed that many adults “didn’t listen to the music or the harmonies or the words. It wasn’t until they became more popular when artists like Mantovani started recording orchestrated versions of their songs with pleasant syrupy sounds that that same middle-aged person started to say, ‘Oh, that’s a nice tune. That’s the Beatles is it?’” (Martin and Hornsby, 1979).

{extract of Mantovani}

Easy-listening cover versions was one route to broader acceptance, but William Mann’s article also made a contribution. In 1999, German academic Michael Bach said, “He [Mann] is essentially appealing to an older generation, to which he belongs, to concentrate on the musical and artistic qualities of the Beatles’ songs and not be put off by volume and electrically altered guitar sounds.” (Bach 1999, p.101, translated from German using Google Translate).

That’s one influence that William Mann had – using his musical authority to encourage older people to listen carefully to the Beatles’ music. The other influence was on musicologists. His article was the first drop in what eventually became a flood of acceptance and respect by musicians and musicologists of types that would previously have dismissed all pop music out of hand.

The subsequent deluge of musicologist writing about The Beatles has taken many forms, not just newspaper articles. There have been many, many articles about The Beatles in academic research journals. Since 2022 there has even been a Journal of Beatles Studies, which publishes research on all aspects of The Beatles. The first book to look seriously at their music, Twilight of the Gods by Wilfrid Mellers, came out in 1973 but now there are quite a few, with Songwriting Secrets of The Beatles by Dominic Pedler standing out for its impressive thoroughness.

The number of people who want to consume all this serious analysis has grown too. There are University courses on the Beatles’ music, including a masters degree in Beatles studies at the University of Liverpool. The book What Goes On by Walter Everett and Tim Riley (2019) is designed to be a textbook for those courses.

William Mann isn’t solely responsible for all this, of course, but he made a contribution in the early days. The jargon he used to describe “Not A Second Time” was pretty horrible, and my aim is to avoid jargon. But I will also come back later and talk about some of the jargon he used because there has been so much discussion about what he may or may not have meant by it and whether it even makes musical sense. But first, what do we know about the writing of the song?

Songwriting

The song was written by John alone. 1963 was the only year when jointly composed songs outnumbered John or Paul solo compositions (Pannell 2023), but solo ones had already reached a majority on With The Beatles. There were three songs by John, one by Paul and three co-compositions, plus one by George.

John mentioned Smokey Robinson as an inspiration for the song in that earlier quote, and there is, of course, an actual Smokey Robinson song on the album: “You Really Got a Hold On Me”.

{extract “You Really Got a Hold On Me”}

One similarity between that song and “Not A Second Time” is that they share a chord sequence. “Not A Second Time” starts with G, Em, G, Em. “You Really Got a Hold On Me” does the same thing but in the key of A, two semitones higher.

{extract of intro of “You Really Got a Hold On Me”}

Maybe it’s that chord sequence that John saw as being characteristic of a Smokey Robinson song.  

Other than that, we don’t know anything about the songwriting process. Almost certainly it was squeezed in between The Beatles’ multitude of other commitments. Looking at their daily schedule in the weeks before the song was recorded (Rees 2022), it’s hard to see how they managed to allocate any time at all to writing. In the 10 days prior to recording “Not A Second Time”, they had rehearsed and recorded a TV performance for ABC Television, gone into ATV house a few days later to watch a playback of the show, flown from Liverpool to London, during which the emergency exit door next to George blew off, recorded three full episodes of their radio show Pop Go The Beatles for the BBC, rehearsed and recorded their contributions to a special edition of Saturday Club for BBC radio, done eight concerts in four towns in a mini-tour of the UK to make up for some earlier cancelled gigs, visited the NEMS office in London, gone clubbing with artists Peter Blake and Jan Haworth, caught the train from Blackpool to London, after which they did a photoshoot and an interview for the Daily Mirror, and also did interviews for the Worcester Evening News, and the BBC Home Service for international broadcast (Lewisohn 1988; Rees 2022). That was completely typical of their lives in 1963. The fact that they also somehow found the time and energy to squeeze in the writing of the songs for With The Beatles is a testament to their incredible work ethic.

Music

We’ve seen that there was always something musically surprising going on in The Beatles’ songs, and “Not A Second Time” is no exception. Starting with the song’s structure, it goes verse, verse, chorus, solo, verse, verse, chorus, outro. What I am calling the chorus – the bit starting “You’re giving me the same old line” – isn’t really very chorus-like. You might prefer to call it the middle eight or bridge, and some have done so.

Given that structure, the solo breaks the song into two halves, apart from the outro. We have verse, verse chorus before the solo and verse, verse, chorus after the solo, using exactly the same lyrics. The whole second half is a repeat of the first half, apart from stretching out one word the second time through. I’m pretty sure that is unique as well. John and Paul did sometimes repeat the first verse as their last verse, seemingly because they had run out of inspiration or energy or time to write something different. But repeating the whole first half of a song was more unusual. We saw in episode 5 that Paul did something similar in “P.S. I Love You”, although in that case the order of the verses was reversed the second time through.

There is no intro at all; they just go straight into the first verse.

{extract of start}

That’s rare for them, but not unique. For example, they did the same thing on “All My Loving”, on the same album. At first the backing is just guitars, bass and piano, but after four bars Ringo joins in, playing the drum pattern he uses throughout the song.

The piano solo in the middle is an instrumental version of the chorus. John sings the first chorus and then they immediately repeat it instrumentally. That’s unusual too. I haven’t been able to think of another song where they do that.

It’s the first Beatles song to use piano as the solo instrument (Lambley 2019). What George Martin plays on the piano is an exact replica of the vocal melody, in a lower register. He uses single notes, no chords, so it’s extremely simple.

{extract of piano solo}

They may have been influenced by various songs from that era that included a melody on a deep twangy guitar. Doing a piano solo at the low end of the keyboard was unusual and they may have considered it a failed experiment as they never did it again. Then again, they generally tried not to repeat themselves, so maybe we shouldn’t read anything into the fact that they didn’t do it again.

The end of the second verse is slightly different from the end of the first verse. The first verse ends with G D, the 1 chord and the 5 chord,

{extract – end of first verse}

while the second verse ends with Am D, the 2 chord and the 5 chord.

{extract – end of second verse}

The inclusion of Am there prepares us for the start of the chorus, which is also on Am.

The outro returns to the chords that start the song and repeats the title. It’s noticeable that John’s double-tracked vocals, which have been almost identical up to this point, diverge somewhat during the latter stages of the outro. After they both sing “no, no, no, no”, one version of John sings “Not A Second Time” again, and the other version sings “no, no, no”.

{extract}

Have you noticed something unusual about the melody John sings in the outro, the second time he sings “Not A Second Time”? Have a listen.

{extract}

What do you think? Sound similar to something else? Yes it does. You’ve heard exactly that melody line on a different song earlier in the album.

{extract from “All I’ve Got to Do”}

“All I’ve Go to Do” was the previous song they recorded that day, just a few hours earlier. The melody of the title line must have lodged in John’s brain and come out when he started to extemporise in “Not A Second Time”. I wonder it if was intentional, and if not, whether they ever realised that John had done this.

The next aspect that defies simple expectations is the number of bars in each section. John completely ignores the usual convention of using multiples of four bars. Each verse has seven bars. It sounds natural, though maybe that’s partly our deep familiarity with the song. I suspect that when we first heard it, our musical brain recognised that something unusual was happening even if we couldn’t identify what it was. Listening carefully, it appears to me that the trick occurs in the fourth bar, which sounds equally like it could be the fourth bar of the first set of four bars and the first of the last four bars. Because it does double duty, the listener fails to notice that there is a bar missing. The way the lyrics flow from the fourth bar into the fifth bar helps to smooth over join.

{extract of fourth and fifth bars}

Paul later achieved the same thing – a seven-bar verse that sounds natural and seamless – in “Yesterday”.

Then the chorus/middle eight pulls the opposite trick, cleverly inserting two extra bars to make it 10 bars long. The “no, no, no” line seems to be where this occurs, but again it’s done seamlessly.

{extract}

If you leave the “no, no, no” line out, you can make it into a traditional-sounding chorus with eight bars.

The arrangement has a prominent piano, played by George Martin. The Beatles release 32 new songs in 1963 and only 7 of them included a keyboard, 5 of those being piano (Pannell 2023). The number of tracks including a keyboard increased a lot in 1964 and increased again in 1967. On With The Beatles the only other piano songs are, “You Really Got a Hold on Me”, and “Money”, played by George Martin, and “Little Child”, played by Paul.

The piano part in “Not A Second Time” is very simple. It sounds like he just plays the chord’s root notes rather than full chords. In the verses he plays on the counts of 1 … and-3 … 1 … and-3,

{extract of piano in verse}

while in the choruses he just plays on the 1 of every second bar.

{extract of piano in chorus}

The “and” beat that George Martin plays on is emphasised by two other instruments as well. I’m talking about the “and” in between the counts of 2 and 3. 1 and 2 AND 3 and 4. Ringo emphasises it with his snare as part of the drum pattern he maintains almost throughout the song.

{extract of drums}

The only deviation from that pattern is when he plays a nice solo fill after each chorus and after the piano solo.

{extract of drum fill}

In addition, George emphasises the same “and” beat in his electric guitar part, which broadly follows Ringo’s snare drum. His part is hard to hear in the mix, but it’s easier to hear in this extract from a video by Sam Popkin where he reproduces both guitar parts, George’s electric and John’s acoustic.

{extract from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lh-OrWJdoyA}

In a number of sources, it’s claimed that George Harrison is not present on the track at all, which would make it the very first song they recorded without playing or singing from all four Beatles. I repeated that claim myself in an article I wrote for the Journal of Beatles Studies in 2023, but I’m sorry to say it’s definitely not true. Once you’ve listened to Sam Popkin’s video and you go back and listen to the original stereo mix, it’s easier to make out the two guitars that are included, one acoustic and one electric. John’s acoustic guitar is strumming along steadily and is picked up by John’s vocal mic so you can hear it in the right channel as well as the left.

Paul’s bass part is very quiet in the mix. You have to focus on it to make it out. When you do, you can hear that it’s rather busy with lots of quarter notes and a lot of them are just playing the root note of the chord. The following extract is very muddy. The bass is so quiet and buried in the mix that the usual AI tools don’t work to separate it. I’ve used EQ to make the bass more audible and to suppress the other instruments. It’s not great, but it’s the best I’ve been able to do. Listen carefully and I hope you’ll be able to make out the bass.

{extract from instrument half of stereo mix}

In my view, it’s not one of Paul’s better efforts on the bass. Unusually, it doesn’t seem to gel well with the guitar, piano or drum parts.

John’s lead vocal is double-tracked throughout.

{extract of John’s vocals}

There are no harmony or backing vocals anywhere in the song. Maybe that’s because they were in a hurry to get it finished. Harmony vocals were one of The Beatles’ secret weapons, but they liked variety too, so they sometimes left them out. On With The Beatles they also didn’t include harmonies on “Don’t Bother Me”, “Til There Was You”, and “Roll Over Beethoven”.

“Not A Second Time” is unusual in the way some of the words are draped across the melody. The usual thing in pop and rock songs is for each syllable of the lyrics to have one note, though there are plenty of exceptions. Sometimes a syllable spans two notes.

{extract “Can’t buy me love”}

Sometimes it slides between notes

{extract “I’m so tired”}

Sometimes it oscillates between two notes.

{extract “I saw her yesterday”}

Occasionally one syllable is sung across a whole series of different notes.

{extract “… hold your hand”}

These are all examples of what is called “melisma”. Extra melisma is thrown in spontaneously by singers of a certain style, with Mariah Carey being an obvious example, but The Beatles used it more sparingly, and it was planned, not spontaneous.

“Not A Second Time” includes melisma to an unusual extent for The Beatles. It uses all four of the approaches I mentioned just now. There are syllables with two notes

{extract “… made me cry”}

With sliding notes

{extract “No, no, no”}

With oscillating notes

{extract “… for you” (first verse)}

And with long series of notes

{extract “… why I cry for you” (third verse)}

In that last line, “why” extends across five notes, “cry” has four notes and “you” has seven. I don’t think there’s another line quite like that in the whole Beatles output. It seems that they tried out extreme melisma in this song and then moved on, never to revisit it. A classic Beatles move.

That covers everything that’s included in the recording of “Not A Second Time”. To finish our look at the music, let’s make a deeper dive into the jargon used by William Mann in his famous article, particularly his use of the term “Aeolian cadence”. Remember that Mann talked about “the Aeolian cadence at the end of ‘Not A Second Time’ (the chord progression which ends Mahler’s Song of the Earth)”.

Musicologists have spent a lot of time – probably too much time – discussing this sentence. I am aware of two academic journal articles and a whole book chapter devoted to trying to make sense of what Mann was saying. The book chapter is in The Songwriting Secrets of The Beatles, by Dominic Pedler, and the journal articles are by Wouter Capitain in Rock Music Studies, and by Michael Bach in a German journal called Jahrbuch Für Volksliedforschung. I needed Google Translate for that one.

Firstly, what is a cadence? The type of cadence that William Mann was talking about is a sequence of chords at the end of a musical phrase. Some cadences naturally sound good to us, such as going from the 5 chord to the 1 chord. If the song is in the key of G, that means playing a D chord and then a G chord. That’s called a perfect cadence, and there is an example in the song before “Not A Second Time” on With The Beatles.

{extract from “Devil in Her Heart” verse}

Other common cadences have names that I am not going to go into, but what is an Aeolian cadence? Surprisingly, it isn’t a standard musical term. Apparently, it was a new term coined by William Mann for his Beatles article (Capitain 2018). There is something called the “Aeolian mode”, which basically means a minor key. The line at the end of the chorus, where John sings the title, goes from D to Em.

{extract}

Mann said that the Aeolian cadence is at the end of the song, but there is no cadence at the end of the song, just a fade out. So most commentators have concluded that this D to Em cadence at the end of the chorus is what he meant. Dominic Pedler said that it makes sense to call this an Aeolian cadence if you interpret the Em chord as a key change to the key of Em, rather than just the sixth chord in the key of G. Presumably that’s what Mann was doing.

Capitain (2018) assumed that the key stayed in G, and he described the term “Aeolian cadence” as “confusing”. He argued that the cadence at the end of the chorus would be better described as “deceptive”, as this is a more recognised term for a case where a musical phrase ends on an unexpected chord. Why is it unexpected? Because, given what we’ve heard earlier in the song, our musical brain would probably expect the chord sequence to go from D to G rather than D to Em.

Pedler (2003) described a Deceptive cadence as “perhaps the flagship of the ‘Violation Of Expectations’” (p.129), which makes us “sit up and listen as if jolted from our slumbers” (p.131). Pedler’s description lines up with something I’ve been pointing out about each the songs we’ve looked at so far: they have all contained one or more musical surprises. The surprises have taken various forms, and now here’s another one – a cadence that confounds our expectations.

Let me quickly deal with the final part of the famous William Mann sentence, where he says that the Aeolian cadence in “Not A Second Time” is the same as “the chord progression which ends Mahler’s Song of the Earth.” It turns out that this is not true. Pedler points out that the Mahler piece Mann refers to doesn’t actually end with any cadence, just a sustained C chord.

{extract of Mahler}

He says that, while the cadence in “Not A Second Time” is meant to be a surprise, the ending of the Mahler piece is “the very antithesis of surprise” (Pedler 2003, p.149). Capitain (2018) agrees and says that, “the musical similarity between Lennon and Mahler is far-fetched, if not non-existent” (Capitain 2018, p.153).

Fair enough, but does this matter? Possibly not. Maybe the key point in all this is one made by Michael Bach. “With his analytical observations, Mann substantiates his claim that the Beatles’ compositions stand out from other pop music.” (Bach 1999, p.101, translated using Google Translate). I guess Mann didn’t need to be strictly accurate on all points to achieve this objective.

 Lyrics

“Not A Second Time” is one of many songs by John where he portrays himself as suffering as a result of some woman. From listening to his songs, you would think that he was constantly being cheated on or abandoned or disappointed in some way. “Misery”, “You Can’t Do That”, “I’ll Cry Instead”, “No Reply”, “I’m a Loser”, and on and on. Of course, most of this disappointment was only happening in John’s mind, and the person who was really behaving badly as a partner was John himself. His wife Cynthia had much, much greater cause for complaint than John did.

It’s interesting to speculate why John was so strongly drawn to portraying himself as a victim in his romantic relationships. It certainly wasn’t due to Cynthia, but maybe he’s remembering previous girlfriends who were much less loyal and tolerant than she was. Was Thelma Pickles, one of his early girlfriends, more like the girl in his romantic victim songs? Not at all. They split up because John hit her and then publicly mocked her because she wouldn’t give him what he wanted when he wanted it (Lewisohn 2013, p.501-502). Clearly, Thelma was the one being badly treated, not John. I suspect that John’s romantic victim songs come from John’s own mental state. We know he had a strong tendency to be jealous – he wrote a song about it – and that he hugely over-reacted to imagined infidelities, or even the potential for an infidelity by Cyn. I think his naturally jealous mind went to the topic of unhappy romantic relationships because it was something he imagined and suspected all too easily. I don’t know that for sure, but it seems a likely explanation to me.

Let’s look at the lyrics. They are easy to interpret and few in number.

 You know you made me cry
I see no use in wondering why
I cry for you

And now you’ve changed your mind
I see no reason to change mine
My crying is through, oooh

You’re giving me the same old line
I’m wondering why
You hurt me then, you’re back again
No, no, no, not a second time

There is nothing that needs explaining there. The entire plot is contained in the first line of each verse and the title: you made me cry, you’ve changed your mind, not a second time. There’s a lot of crying going on. It’s mentioned in three of the six lines of the verses.

One interesting suggestion made by Capitain (2018), among others, is that John’s assertion that he won’t allow this girl to hurt him a second time is not convincing. He’s protesting so much that he’s really trying to convince himself, but he’ll probably give in and go back to her. There might be something to that, but personally I doubt that John intended us to take that interpretation rather than the straightforward, face-value one.

Recording process

September 11, 1963 was one year to the day since the recording session with the session musician Andy White on drums, brought in to replace Ringo for the recording of “PS I Love You” but also helping The Beatles to record the more common version of “Love Me Do” and the first recorded version of “Please Please Me” (Lewisohn 2013).

At the time of that session, The Beatles were almost unknown outside the worlds of live music in Liverpool and Hamburg. One year on, The Beatles were comfortably the biggest act in the UK. They had released “She Loves You” a couple of weeks earlier and it was in the process of becoming their third straight number 1 single and the biggest-selling single of all time until “Mull of Kintyre”.

They had not yet reached the extreme level of Beatlemania that would become inescapable over the following couple of months, but their concerts were already quite hysterical and their arrival at and departure from concert venues already required police escorts and creative tricks and diversions (Rees 2022).

We’ve seen that their workload by this stage was insane, but they still managed to come up with songs as great as “She Loves You”, “All My Loving”, and “I Want to Hold Your Hand”. But not everything they wrote was at that incredible standard. The need to come up with enough songs for a new album under extreme time pressure meant that the quality had to vary. “Not A Second Time” was one of several original tracks on With The Beatles that were good but not at their highest standard.

There was also limited time for the recording process for these songs. On September 11 they worked on five original tracks for the album over two recording sessions from 2:30 pm to 10:15 pm. These were “I Wanna Be Your Man”, “Little Child”, “All I’ve Got to Do”, “Not A Second Time”, and “Don’t Bother Me”. Of these, “All I’ve Got to Do” and “Not A Second Time” were finished this day.

“Not A Second Time” took just 90 minutes from start to finish, apart from mixing (Lewisohn 1988). They started by recording five takes of the basic instrumental track, with guitar, guitar, bass and drums on one track and John’s vocal on another (Hammack 2023). Take 5 was best, and onto this they overdubbed George Martin’s piano and a second copy of John’s lead vocal to create a double-tracked sound (Hammack 2023). And that was it! Simple and efficient, and without any frills.

Instruments

For the songs recorded in 1963, the question of which specific instruments they played is fairly easily answered. If you can hear an acoustic guitar, it’s one of the Gibson J160Es that they acquired in September 1962. That’s what John is playing on this song (Hammack 2023). Jerry Hammack says that George is also playing a Gibson J160E, but I agree with Sam Popkin that he is playing an electric guitar, which would have been his Gretsch Country Gentleman. It was the first of two Country Gentlemen that George would eventually own. George bought the first one in June 1963 for about £260. It must have been one of the last guitars that they had to actually pay for. Andy Babiuk (2015) tells us that it was a model G6122 which “had a double-cutaway two-inch-thick hollow body with painted-on f-holes” (Babiuk 2015, p.147-148). It had humbucking pickups and all the metal hardware was gold-plated! Paul was playing his original 1961 Hofner 500/1 violin bass – the one that got stolen in 1972 and rediscovered in 2023. Ringo played his 1963 Ludwig kit with oyster black pearl colouring.

Mixes and versions

There have only ever been two proper mixes of the song: the mono and stereo mixes made at Abbey Road in September and October 1963 (Lewisohn 1988). The stereo mix has all the instruments on the left and the voices on the right, although there is quite a bit of bleed of John’s acoustic guitar into the vocal microphone. The American stereo mix apparently has extra reverb added, although it’s not as obvious as on some of their other early releases. The US mono mix is a fold down of the US stereo mix, rather than using the mono mix made by George Martin (Wild 2019).

Live performances

It seems that the only time The Beatles ever played “Not A Second Time” was during the 90 minutes they spent recording it on September 11, 1963. They never played it live, or on the BBC, or during the Get Back sessions. It was never done on TV, or in a movie or in a cartoon, or anything. It was strictly album-only.

Cover versions

By Beatles standards, “Not A Second Time” has relatively few cover versions. I can’t find any that have Beatles connections, but there are a few by well-known acts.

Robert Palmer https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zBiXCDWELyo covered it on his 1980 album Clues. His version is quite heavy, which suits the song, but it is marred by a cheesy synthesiser solo in place of George Martin’s piano. Palmer took the very brave step of substituting some new lyrics of his own to replace the repeated verses in the second half of the song. They actually work quite well in the song, although it’s hard to feel comfortable about someone changing a Beatles song.

{extract of Robert Palmer}

The Pretenders https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L_sABVC-lSA released their cover as a single B side in 1990. It is quite similar to The Beatles’ original arrangement and Chrissie Hynde’s singing on it is absolutely beautiful. The bass is much more audible than Paul’s is on the original, and I have to admit that the bassline is probably superior.

{extract of The Pretenders}

The Smithereens are huge Beatles fans, to the extent of faithfully re-recording Meet The Beatles in its entirety. Of course, the resulting album, Meet The Smithereens, includes “Not A Second Time” as the last song. Their arrangements of the songs are not slavish reproductions of the originals, though they’re close. Their version of “Not A Second Time” has less prominent piano than the original, and there are two electric guitars with somewhat beefier sounds.  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9pUcsZRNZT4

{extract of The Smithereens}

Two other covers I’d like to hear but haven’t been able to find are by Flamin’ Groovies from 1992 and Roseanne Cash from 2002. Apart from them, the other covers listed online are not by acts I know. http://beatlescovers.bizerks.com/Not%20a%20Second%20Time.htm

Other thoughts

Here’s a fun coincidence. As I mentioned earlier, in the week before the recording of “Not A Second Time”, The Beatles recorded three episodes of Pop Go The Beatles for BBC radio. Where did they do this? In London, in Aeolian Hall! This was in New Bond Street, and in the early 1960s about 20 shows per week were being recorded or performed there for the BBC. Pop Go The Beatles was just one of those. As I said, The Beatles never played “Not A Second Time” for a BBC session, so Aeolian Hall never got to hear their Aeolian cadence.

Conclusion

Many of The Beatles’ recordings before 1966 were made under severe time pressure. It’s surprising how few of them feel like they needed more time spent on them, but to my ears, “Not A Second Time” does have that feeling. It would have benefited if there had been time for Paul to write a couple more verses or maybe tweak the chorus melody. The instrument parts could have been worked on some more, and the piano solo, in particular, could have been made more interesting. Maybe some Shirelles-style vocals and some percussion would have perked things up. But if you are trying to record five original songs in less than one day, songs that the band has not rehearsed or played live, then you can’t spend time sweating the details.

Despite the rush, “Not A Second Time” does have some distinctive features. It was the first Beatles song to use a piano as the solo instrument. There were unusual numbers of bars in each section, 7 in the verse and 10 in the chorus. The way that the second half of the song is almost a repeat of the first half is unusual as well. It’s notable for being commonly identified as the first Beatles recording to not include all four of them playing, even though that’s not actually true - they are all included. It’s also notable for being singled out in the first published piece of writing by a musicologist to take The Beatles’ music seriously. Ironically the article by William Mann spawned an ongoing debate about whether the musical features he identified are actually present in the song, and whether he may have confused it with a different song.

In 1980, John commented that the term “aeolian cadence” sounds like it’s referring to an exotic bird, which is really a fitting response to Mann’s pompous and pretentious prose, but Mann does deserve credit for being the first in a long and still-growing line of musicologists to recognise The Beatles’ greatness. Pedler’s description of him as “the father of Beatles musicology” (Pedler 2003, p.146) seems fair.

That’s it for this episode. Let me know what you think in the comments on everysoundthereis.net, where you can also find the transcript. Join me next time on Every Sound There Is for an in-depth exploration of another Beatles song.

Theme music by Marcus Phelan with Stefan Koch. Music in the section announcements by Stefan Koch, David Pannell, Marcus Phelan; and from the Gimme Some Truth podcast, Obadiah Jones and his mixing engineer Liam Narrie. Voice-overs by Michael Burton.

References

Babiuk, A. (2015). Beatles Gear: All the Fab Four’s Instruments from Stage to Studio, The Ultimate Edition, Backbeat, Milwaukee.

Bach, Michael. “‘What Songs the Beatles Sang…’: Der Musikkritiker William Mann Und Seine Erste Rezension Eines Popmusikalischen Phänomens.” Jahrbuch Für Volksliedforschung 44 (1999): 95–104.

The Beatles (2000). The Beatles Anthology, Chronicle Books, San Francisco.

Capitain, W. (2018). Not A Second Time? John Lennon’s Aeolian Cadence Reconsidered, Rock Music Studies 5(2), 142-160.

Everett, W. and Riley, T. (2019). What Goes On: The Beatles, Their Music, and Their Time, Oxford University Press, New York.

Hammack, J. (2023). The Beatles, Recording Reference Manual, Volume 1, My Bonnie through Beatles For Sale (1961-1964), 8th edition, Gearfab, Ontario.

Lambley, S. (2019). And the Band Begins to Play: The Definitive Guide to the Songs of the Beatles, Slide, London.

Lewisohn, M. (1988). The Complete Beatles Recording Sessions, Hamlyn, London.

Lewisohn, M. (2013). All These Years, Volume 1: Tune In, Extended Special Edition, Little, Brown, London.

Martin, G. and Hornsby, J. (1979). All You Need is Ears: The Inside Personal Story of the Genius Who Created The Beatles, Macmillan, London.

Pannell, D.J. (2023). Quantitative analysis of the evolution of the Beatles’ releases for EMI, 1962 – 1970, The Journal of Beatles Studies, Spring/Autumn, 65-90. https://doi.org/10.3828/jbs.2023.5

Pedler, Dominic. The Songwriting Secrets of the Beatles. London: Omnibus Press, 2003.

Rees, D. (2022). The Beatles 1963: A Year in the Life, Omnibus Press.

Wenner, J. (1971). Lennon Remembers, Straight Arrow, San Francisco.

Wild, A. (2019). On Track … The Beatles: An A-Z Guide to Every Song, Sonic Bond.

David Pannell

November 2026

Next
Next

6. With A Little Help From My Friends